Screenplay by Jonathan Nolan & Christopher Nolan
Story by Christopher Nolan & David S. Goyer
Directed by Christopher Nolan
“You crossed the line first, sir. You hammered them…and in their desperation, they turned to a man they didn’t fully understand. Some men aren’t looking for anything logical. They can’t be bought, bullied, reasoned or negotiated with. Some men just want to watch the world burn.”
OK…let’s get some of the fluffy requirements out of the way first…
COMPLAINT #1
The film is (ever-so-slightly) TOO long. About 20 minutes could have been trimmed in various places, which would have increased the pace beyond the speed of light, yet maintained the intensity and the integrity of the film.
COMPLAINT #2
Rachel still doesn’t quite do it for me as a character. Maggie Gyllenhaal is better in the role than Katie Holmes…but her chemistry with both Aaron Echhart & Christian Bale isn’t exactly scorching.
COMPLAINT #3
Bale’s Batman voice remains…odd…and there’s still no hummable, iconic theme tune.
Other than that, this is near-mathematical PERFECTION. From the late Heath Ledger’s astonishing performance as the Joker, and going down from there…no other mistake was made to bring us this masterpiece of drama. And make no mistake…this IS drama. Shocking, brilliant, twisted, magnificent drama. The kind of drama that is worth the (expensive) price of admission to a modern movie theatre.
Which leads me to the rest of this critique. I could go on and on about why I enjoyed The Dark Knight. Instead, I’m going to take a different road: the reason recent DC Comics films are so much more satisfying than their Marvel Comics counter-parts.
In the Marvel movie universe, they have refined the popcorn movie into high art. All three Spider-Mans, Fantastic Four, The Incredible Hulk, and (from all I’ve heard, and its box office results) Iron Man have followed an colourful action-adventure format, with a few washes of emotions…with a very hit-and-miss approach to the latter element.
All Marvel attempts to reach for something more…something deeper, and more resonant, have fallen victim to various failures. The first two brilliant X-Men films degenerated into a third and final runaround of bloated cliches and shoot-em-up bangs and flashes. The original 2003 version of The Hulk ended up being far too psychologically deep and dark for its audience. Since then, Marvel has stuck to its more successful popcorn format. Successful & a hell of a good time…but not exactly earth-shattering. The string of disappointments (Daredevil, The Punisher, Elektra, Ghost Rider, even Spider-Man 3’s critical mauling) speak as loudly as the successes.
On the other hand, since 2005, DC has taken advantage of the fact that it owns, as comics and graphic novelist extraordinaire Frank Miller himself states, the iconic GODS of the comic universe. There is Superman, there is Batman, and there is Wonder Woman. Everyone else falls somewhere below…
These characters are mythic: archetypes that have resonated over generations, and become part of the pop culture in a way only Spiderman has managed to achieve from the Marvel universe of characters. The DC gods represent all the best and worst facets of humanity, and they offer a canvas far deeper and far more interesting than most of the Marvel line-up, the X-Men aside (at least, when directed by Bryan Singer).
Batman Begins set the tone in 2005 - it wasn’t a kids movie. It’s an adult drama, epic in scope, epic in emotional resonance, and set Batman as the god of the human underworld. All our fears, phobias, and base emotions…wrapped up in a black cowl and haunting the streets, fighting the darkness with an even greater darkness.
Superman Returns presented the flip-side in 2006. Whereas Batman is needed but unwelcome - even despised - by the ambivalent people he protects, Superman returns like an eagle descending from heaven. The god of light and power, the protector of all that is good and pure: in short, the saviour. Everyone wants him, yet their equally-fearful awe keeps him at a distance…and leaves behind the uncomfortable question of whether human destiny should be left in the hands of such super beings.

This trend intensifies in The Dark Knight. The world Batman defends is now the world Batman has created. It has spawned a terrible beast (in the form of the psychotic Joker) that takes advantage of his new rules by ignoring them…and daring the gods to play along or be swept aside. At the same time, the everyday citizens of Gotham try to control their destiny as best as they can, in the shadow of a battle between demons and dark gods they can only barely comprehend. The Marvel Comics universe doesn’t even come close to achieveing this Tolkein-esque depth that the DC gods offer to the audience. Certainly, no Marvel film comes close to the moment on the river ferries, where two separate human decisions validate Batman’s faith in the citizens of Gotham, in spite of the hell in which they find themselves.
The Dark Knight is not a movie to bring children to watch. This is a movie that explores the raw, unhinged power of darkness, depression, shattered dreams, and madness. It takes the everyday paranoia of terrorist threats, fears of crime & human weakness, and twists it like a sponge, squeezing out every last drop of black gold from such story potential. It’s a movie filled with actors who embrace & dance with its tragic-yet-uplifting depths of operatic & Jacobean potential. It has a writer/director with such a powerful, clear vision that the rhythms of the film literally pulse from the screen.
DC made its choice. It has chosen to reach for depth, for art, for something that is worthy of the iconic characters that lead the roster of its fictional universe. With The Dark Knight, they have easily gone 3 for 3 over the last three years. All that needs to happen now is for a film to reflect the team up & astonishing friendship between its two god-like characters (as shown in its most popular comic - Superman/Batman) and I may very well die happy.
The film … 9.5
The DC renaissance … 10+
Who am I?
Why am I Here?
Yes, I'm a giant robot of destruction. I have a huge brain, sarcastic software, and small people flee in terror when they see me.
In another reality, I'm also a teacher. That tends to balance things out nicely.